Every Neil Gaiman adaptation ranked

With the success of Netflix sand man, interest in others is renewed Neil Gaiman adaptations, and here they are ranked from worst to best. Gaiman is a wizard with a pen and has amassed a library of notable literary works since the 1980s. He is known for his unique style of dark fantasy stories that span a variety of media, including comics, graphic novels, fiction, and nonfiction. With his success as an author, it is no surprise that many of his notable works have been adapted for the screen. Gaiman has worked with nearly every major streaming platform and network to bring his literary creations to life. With more touch customizations, like Amazon’s Anansi Boysthere’s certainly no shortage of great research material in his ever-growing library.


In the early 1980s, Neil Gaiman started out as a journalist. As he became interested in fantasy and science fiction, his interest peaked after reading Swamp thing by Alan Moore. After befriending Moore, Gaiman took over A miracle worker and contributed to Moore’s The guards series. Officially joining DC Comics in 1987, Gaiman began his successful career as a comic book writer. His works have stood the test of time, and his creative vision defined the era for which he is best known, that of the graphic novel revolution of the 1990s..

Related: Why The Sandman Took So Long To Make And How It Exceeded All Expectations

While future adaptations like Good signs season 2 is likely to change the landscape, here are the Neil Gaiman adaptations ranked from worst to best. Works such as are not listed Beowulf and MirrorMask, which are inspired by some of Gaiman’s stories, but are not direct adaptations. See where his adaptations fall on the scale.

10. How to Talk to Girls at Parties (2018)

How to talk to girls at parties

Based on the 2006 short story of the same name. How to talk to girls at parties was published by A24 in 2018. Despite a cast that included notable stars such as Ella Fanning and Nicole Kidman, the film was not well received and currently has a 47% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. The film explores interesting themes and manages to be quite entertaining, but lacks depth. The film is currently available to watch on HBO MAX.

9. Probable stories by Neil Gaiman (2016)

Neil Gaiman Probable Stories

On his way to match the number of Stephen King adaptations, Gaiman has many underrated TV works, such as Neil Gaiman’s Probable Stories. The Shudder exclusive is low on the list because it was shortened to only four episodes. The anthology series was based on Gaiman’s short stories, with the writer appearing as a sort of narrator in each episode.

8. Neverwhere (1996)

Neil Gaiman Never

Unlike the others on the list, Never it was adapted into a novel as an addition to the series. Never it marked one of Gaiman’s first forays into British television. The show featured a hidden world called London Below that featured people who were invisible to the people of London Above and centered on Richard Mayhew as he moved between these strange spaces.

Related: Netflix’s Sandman makes dreams better than comics in one key way

7. Stardust (2007)

Tristan and Yvaine smile aboard the Stardust

Star dust, which featured a young Charlie Cox before his MCU and Daredevil fame, is Gaiman’s first mainstream big screen adaptation. Along with Cox, the film had an all-star cast including Robert De Niro, Michelle Pfeiffer, Henry Cavill, and Claire Danes, among others. The film is a romantic fantasy set in the fictional city of Wall in Great Britain and a magical world called Stormhold. star dust it was originally picked up by Miramax in 1998, but problems during development killed the project. Gaiman waited until a satisfactory offer came, which eventually came from Paramount, with Matthew Vaughn to write, produce and direct. Vaughn drew his inspiration from princess bride, and so the underrated fantasy adaptation was launched.

6. DC Showcase: Death (2019)

DC Showcase Death

Inspired Sandman’s version of Death, the animated short was the first time one of The Endless appeared on screen. It was released as a bonus together Wonder Woman: Bloodlines and is located in Gotham City. The role of Death was voiced by actress Jamie Chung, who was recently seen in Dexter: New blood. In much the same vein as the comic, the short followed Death as she helped a man from Gotham City transition into the afterlife.

5. American Gods (2017-2021)

Wednesday and Shadow Moon from American Gods.

Starzova American Gods adapted probably Gaiman’s most successful and popular novel. The series got off to a hot start with an excellent first season that showcased Gaiman’s unique take on various religious and mythological pantheons. In the second season, there was a change of presenter and some actors, which affected the quality of the series. American Gods it ended after season 3 before the story could be completed, leaving it on a cliffhanger. Despite the abrupt ending and problems with the production, the adaptation had its bright spots as a somewhat faithful depiction of the novel.

4. Lucifer (2016-2021)


Lucifer is a loose adaptation The sand manfight the devil. Starring Tom Ellis as Lucifer Morningstar, the series originally premiered on Fox to mixed reviews. Lucifer it ran for three seasons on Fox before being canceled due to lower-than-expected ratings. The series was picked up by Netflix and enjoyed three more well-rated seasons, becoming one of Netflix’s most popular series. Some were disappointed that Tom Ellis was not cast as Lucifer The sand man, but the truth is that his version was quite different from Gaiman’s in the comics. The role went to Gwendoline Christie, who did a fantastic job portraying the character as intended.

Related: Why The Sandman Season 2 Isn’t Guaranteed (Despite Being #1 On Netflix)

3. Good signs (2019-)

Michael Sheen and David Tennant in Good Omens

Good signs is an adaptation of the 1990 novel, which Gaiman co-wrote with Terry Pratchett. Good signs season 1 was released on Amazon Prime Video in 2019, starring Michael Sheen and David Tennant, with Gaiman as showrunner. The show revolves around the unlikely duo of the angel Aziraphale and the demon Crowley, who try to prevent Armageddon after enjoying life on Earth. Like the novel, it riffs and pokes fun at a lot of religious themes and the battle between good and evil. Initially intended to be a six-episode limited series, it gained popularity with the second season. Good signs season 2 will answer the big questions; with no source material to draw from, it will be a completely original story.

2. The Sandman (2022)

Sandman Netflix Dream

Thirty years in the making, The sand man, based on Neil Gaiman’s popular comic book series, has finally hit the screens. After a long time in development hell, passing through many hands, it found a home on Netflix, which has already proven successful for Gaiman with Lucifer. The series stars Tom Sturridge as Dream of the Endless, alongside an impressive cast of Gwendoline Christie, Jenna Coleman and David Thewlis. The first season retells the first two volumes of the comic. The sand man does a great job of making the show cohesive while incorporating multiple story arcs. The adaptation met and even exceeded expectations with a great cast and a story that is faithful to the source. With the success of the first season, there is hope for a Sandman season 2

1. Coraline (2009)

Coraline - top 10 stop motion animated films

Coraline is a stop-motion animated film based on the novel of the same name by Neil Gaiman. The film was directed by Henry Selick, who directed The Nightmare Before Christmas. Coraline it was critically acclaimed and even received an Oscar nomination. Dakota Fanning played the notable role of Coraline Jones, the titular character who discovers a parallel universe behind the living room door. This discovery sets off a journey that culminates in Coraline rescuing her parents from the Other Mother, who wants to replace their eyes with buttons. At the end of the screening in the cinema, Coraline became the third highest-grossing stop-motion film of all time and the biggest success of a Neil Gaiman adjustment he has enjoyed so far.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *